Home › Selling & Pricing › Member Pricing Apps
Head to headAs of October 2026
Members Win vs SparkLayer: Member Pricing Compared
Short answer
SparkLayer scores 70 and Members Win scores 65 in our October 2026 scoring. SparkLayer is a B2B platform with price lists, 391 reviews at 4.8 and plans from $49. Members Win is a simple tag-based pricing tool: free for unlimited rules and 25 member orders a month, $9.99 for unlimited, with the member price shown while browsing.
Pick by situation
VIP or member prices, simple
Members Win. Tag a customer, pick a percent, done. Free for 25 member orders a month.
Wholesale price lists and B2B
SparkLayer. Price lists and tiers, from $49 a month.
Tiny wholesale test
SparkLayer Basic. Free for 3 price lists and 5 orders a month.
| Feature | Members Win | SparkLayer |
|---|---|---|
| Rating (reviews) | None yet (0) | 4.8 (391) |
| Launched | July 3, 2026 | April 28, 2021 |
| Built for Shopify | No | No |
| Free plan | Storefront badge, unlimited rules, 25 member orders a month | Basic: 3 price lists, 5 orders a month |
| Paid plans | Pro $9.99 a month: unlimited member orders, priority support | Starter $49, Growth $149, Pro $299 |
| Member price on product page | Yes, stated | Not stated |
| Price types | Percent discount on all or tagged products | Price lists |
| Uses existing customer tags | Yes | Not stated |
| Complaints | None (no reviews) | 6 one-star, 5 two-star: charged on free plan (October 2026), hard tiered setup (January 2026), confusing setup (April 2026) |
These two sit at opposite ends of the same category: one is a platform, the other is a single feature.
Score sheet
| Check | Members Win | SparkLayer B2B & Wholesale |
|---|---|---|
| Price rule by customer tag or group (10 pts) | ✓ | ✓ |
| Member price shown on the product page while browsing (stated) (10 pts) | ✓ | ✗ |
| More than one tier, group or price list on free or entry plan (10 pts) | ✓ | ✓ |
| Price types beyond one flat % (tiers, price lists, shipping) (10 pts) | ✗ | ✓ |
| Free plan includes the core feature (10 pts) | ✓ | ✓ |
| No % of value, per-order or overage fee listed (10 pts) | ✓ | ✓ |
| All plan prices shown on the listing (5 pts) | ✓ | ✓ |
| A paid plan with no cap on the core action (10 pts) | ✓ | ✗ |
| Built for Shopify badge (10 pts) | ✗ | ✗ |
| Rated 4.5 or higher with 10+ reviews (10 pts) | ✗ | ✓ |
| Track record: 100+ reviews or launched by Oct 2023 (5 pts) | ✗ | ✓ |
| Total score | 65 of 100 | 70 of 100 |
SparkLayer leads by 15 points on trust (rating and track record). Members Win leads by 10 on cost, because it lists a paid plan with no cap. Capability is level at 30 each: SparkLayer wins the price types check, Members Win wins the stated product page price check.
Members Win home: two steps, a pricing rule and storefront display.
Where SparkLayer wins
Scale. Price lists, three paid tiers up to $299 and 391 reviews. If you run wholesale with many price levels, start here.
Where Members Win wins
Simplicity and price. The first rule takes under a minute per the listing, the free plan is generous and Pro is $9.99. It does not create duplicate products or discount codes. A logged-out visitor sees the regular price and a Join free prompt.
How we would choose
Fewer than three price levels and a single member group: Members Win. Many customer groups, price lists or net terms: SparkLayer or another B2B suite. See the full ranking and the Wholesale Pricing Discount test.
Questions people ask
Is Members Win free?
Yes. The free plan lists a storefront badge, unlimited pricing rules and 25 member orders per month. Pro is $9.99 a month for unlimited member orders and priority support.
Which is better for wholesale?
SparkLayer, which is a B2B platform with price lists. Members Win's listing does not list net terms, order forms or registration forms.
Does SparkLayer have a free plan?
Yes, Basic: 3 price lists and 5 orders a month. An October 2026 reviewer said they were charged despite being on it and ignored by support, so check billing after install.
